The Role of Comparative Negligence In Personal Injury Cases

Big Leap • March 6, 2023

The complexities of personal injury cases can have a profound influence on their outcomes, one such factor being comparative negligence. Comparative negligence is an established legal standard used to determine each participant’s level of fault in an accident, as well as the ensuing damages and injuries that result from it. In this article, we will delve deeper into how your own actions may impact any case where comparative negligence becomes relevant.

What is comparative negligence?

Comparative negligence is an important legal concept employed in personal injury cases to apportion blame. It allows the court to allocate fault between a plaintiff who has suffered harm and a defendant being sued for damages, with some states using it as a defense argument that the injured party’s actions contributed to their own injuries.

How does comparative negligence work?

Comparative negligence can be applied in one of two ways: pure comparative negligence or modified comparative negligence. In a pure comparative negligence state, the plaintiff can recover damages even if they are 99% at fault for their own injuries, but their award will be reduced by their percentage of fault. For example, if a plaintiff is found to be 50% at fault for their own injuries, they will only be able to recover 50% of their total damages.

In a modified comparative negligence state, the plaintiff can only recover damages if they are found to be less than a certain percentage at fault (usually 50%). If they are found to be more than that percentage at fault, they cannot recover damages at all.

How can your own actions impact your case?

If you’re engaged in a personal injury case , your actions before the accident could have an impact on the result. For example, if you get into a car crash and it’s determined that you were texting while driving, partial liability for your injuries can be assigned to you–which will likely decrease whatever compensation is given to you.

If you have been hurt on someone else’s property, it is possible to reduce your damages if liability can be established. However, if evidence shows that you were trespassing or being careless when the injury occurred, a court may decide that you are partially liable for your own injuries and adjust how much they will provide in compensation accordingly.

It’s important to note that even if you are found to be partially at fault for your injuries, you may still be able to recover damages. However, the amount you are able to recover will be reduced by your percentage of fault.

Comparative negligence is a legal concept that can drastically sway the outcome of any personal injury lawsuit. Therefore, if you are considering filing for a claim after an accident, it’s paramount to comprehend how your own behavior could determine the results of your case. To ensure that all rights and entitled compensation be safeguarded in this process, enlisting assistance from an adept personal injury lawyer would prove beneficial.

A red car with a broken windshield is sitting on the side of a road.
July 16, 2025
Learn how car accidents impact mental health, from PTSD to anxiety, and why emotional recovery matters for victims and personal injury claims.
June 18, 2025
Navigating an insurance claim can be challenging under the best of circumstances. Claims tend to be time-consuming, stressful, and complicated, especially when you are dealing with injuries or property damage. However, what happens when the insurance company that is supposed to protect you fails to uphold its legal and ethical duties? In Nevada, this failure may constitute what is known as insurance bad faith. This article explores what insurance bad faith entails, the legal remedies available to policyholders, and practical advice on how to recognize possible bad faith tactics. Insurance Bad Faith Defined Insurance bad faith occurs when an insurance provider does not act with honesty, fairness, and good faith toward its policyholders. Policies are written with the expectation that insurers will investigate claims, evaluate damages, and pay out legitimate claims on time. When this standard is not met⁠—due to, for example, unjustified refusals to pay, unwarranted claim denials, or extreme claim delays⁠—a policyholder may have grounds to claim that the insurer acted in bad faith. In Nevada, insurers are bound by both statutory and common law principles designed to prevent misconduct. Whether you hold a health, auto, or homeowner's policy, your insurer’s obligation to deal fairly and in good faith remains the same. The insurance regulations in this state are enforced in part by the Nevada Division of Insurance , which is responsible for overseeing insurance companies and protecting consumers from unfair or dishonest practices. Common Bad Faith Tactics While conflicts can arise in any insurance claim, certain patterns indicate potential bad faith dealings. The following examples help illustrate the types of behavior policyholders should watch for: Unreasonable Delays: Timeliness is a key factor in handling claims. Although investigations may require time, a claim that drags on far beyond normal processing periods without a valid reason can be a red flag. Inadequate Investigations: Insurance companies should conduct thorough and impartial investigations of losses. Taking shortcuts, ignoring evidence, or dismissing expert reports might constitute unfair treatment of a claim. Misrepresentation of Policy Terms: When an insurer misrepresents or inaccurately explains the details of coverage, it deprives the policyholder of the ability to make informed decisions. Transparency is essential in any insurer-policyholder relationship. Unjust Denials or Underpayment: Denying a claim outright, or offering an unreasonably low settlement without explanation, can indicate that the company is neglecting its duty to act per the policy’s terms and the relevant law. Complaint trends often highlight these types of tactics as leading causes of consumer frustration in the insurance industry. By staying aware of these red flags, you can better protect yourself against potential misconduct. Nevada Law and Insurance Bad Faith Nevada law protects policyholders by imposing certain duties on insurers. These include the duty to communicate promptly, investigate claims thoroughly, and treat policyholders with honesty. When an insurer breaches these duties, the policyholder may have legal remedies beyond the initial value of the claim, including the possibility of recovering compensation for emotional distress, attorney’s fees, and punitive damages. Nevada’s Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act sets forth clear guidelines regarding how insurers should handle claims. This statute forbids various actions, such as unreasonably delaying claim payments and misrepresenting policy provisions. Violations can lead to regulatory action and a civil lawsuit by the aggrieved policyholder. Courts in Nevada generally look for two main factors when examining an alleged bad faith claim: (1) whether the insurer withholding benefits lacked a reasonable basis, and (2) whether the insurer had knowledge or should have known that no reasonable basis existed to deny the claim. If both of these elements are met, it can pave the way for a successful bad faith lawsuit. Potential Damages in Bad Faith Claims When an insurer is found liable for bad faith, a policyholder may be awarded more than just the unpaid policy benefits. Depending on the specifics of the case, damages might include: Compensatory Damages: These aim to reimburse the policyholder for direct financial losses arising from the insurer’s misconduct. Emotional Distress: Courts recognize that a bad faith denial or protracted claims process can lead to anxiety and emotional turmoil, particularly when it impedes medical treatment or daily living activities. Punitive Damages: In especially egregious cases, an insurer may be required to pay punitive damages. These are meant to punish wrongdoing and deter similar conduct in the future. These types of damages vary considerably based on individual case circumstances and Nevada’s existing jurisprudence. If you suspect you may be dealing with a situation involving bad faith, reach out for personalized guidance. Steps to Protect Your Interests Being informed and taking action can help you safeguard your rights: Maintain Detailed Records: Keep track of every communication you have with the insurance company. Documentation simplifies proving bad faith behavior if it becomes necessary. Save emails, letters, estimates, and any official documents. Know Your Policy: Thoroughly review your coverage. If you understand the specifics of your policy—limits, exclusions, and conditions—you will be more prepared to recognize any misrepresentations. Ask for Explanations: If an insurer denies your claim, request a written explanation that references relevant policy provisions. A refusal or inability to clarify can raise questions about their handling of the matter. File a Complaint: If you believe your insurer is not cooperating properly, you can file a complaint with the Nevada Division of Insurance , which investigates consumer grievances. Consult an Attorney: Tackling complex cases of bad faith without legal counsel can be difficult. An experienced legal team with a focus on personal injury and insurance law can guide you through the process and fight on your behalf. Legal Guidance Matters Insurance disputes can be legally complex, especially when bad faith allegations arise. While many policyholders attempt to handle claim disputes on their own, even minor missteps can undermine an otherwise valid claim. Having skilled legal counsel can: Level the Playing Field: Insurance companies typically have the resources to contest disputes aggressively. An attorney can help counter these tactics by presenting legal arguments, gathering evidence, and negotiating on your behalf. Provide Clarity: A lawyer clarifies your rights and outlines potential avenues of relief. This knowledge helps you make informed decisions that align with your best interests. Position You for Fair Compensation: Attorneys with experience in insurance bad faith cases know how to accurately value claims. This ensures you are compensated fairly for financial losses, emotional distress, and any other related damages. A Way Forward Understanding the concept of insurance bad faith in Nevada is essential for anyone navigating a difficult insurance claim. Knowing your rights, staying vigilant for red flags, and taking prompt action when necessary can all prove decisive in protecting your best interests. While insurance companies have a duty to treat policyholders fairly, not all follow this principle as they should. By recognizing potential bad faith tactics early, documenting every step of your claim, and seeking professional help, you place yourself in the strongest position to secure the coverage and benefits you are entitled to receive. Stay proactive, remain informed, and remember that you do not have to navigate the complexities of an insurance dispute alone. Our team at Ahlander Injury Law is committed to guiding policyholders through every stage of the claims process, ensuring fair treatment and advocating for the compensation you deserve. If you suspect your insurer has handled your claim in bad faith or if you simply want guidance on your current insurance dispute, Ahlander Injury Law offers insights and personalized support for policyholders in Nevada. Contact us to discuss your concerns and explore your legal options.
June 4, 2025
Experiencing a slip and fall accident can be unsettling and confusing, especially when it happens without warning. A seemingly minor fall could lead to unexpected injuries, mounting medical bills, and stress about your legal options. While every situation is different, you can take key actions right away to protect your well-being and preserve your rights should you decide to seek legal recourse. Assess Your Safety and Health First Your top priority after any slip and fall should always be your safety. If you can move without further injury, carefully get to a safe place away from potential hazards like wet floors, uneven surfaces, or obstructive debris. If you feel dizzy or in severe pain, remain where you are and, if possible, ask someone to call for medical assistance. Adrenaline can mask injuries, so never assume you are fine just because you feel minimal discomfort in the immediate aftermath. Recognizing the possibility of internal injuries or hidden trauma is vital. Even as you focus on regaining your composure, keep in mind that the steps you take in these first moments can significantly affect the success of any future claim should you decide to consult with a professional. Document the Scene and Preserve Evidence Once you feel safe, documenting the scene becomes critical. Photographs and witness statements can protect you later if the cause of the accident is disputed. Use your phone’s camera to capture: The exact location of your fall and any contributing factors (e.g., liquid spills, uneven flooring, or loose cords) Warning signs (or lack thereof) indicating a hazard Weather and lighting conditions if relevant (especially important for outdoor incidents) Any visible injuries you have sustained Keep copies of any pictures you take, and ask witnesses for their contact information. Ask them if they noticed any specific hazard, witnessed your fall, or have any additional details they can share. These accounts can bolster your case by corroborating your version of events, which can be crucial if legal disputes arise later. Seek Prompt Medical Evaluation Even if you think your injuries are minor, seeking immediate medical attention is crucial for your health and for establishing a clear record that links the incident to your condition. Slip and fall accidents often result in injuries that do not always present immediate symptoms. A trained healthcare professional can detect and document any hidden issues, which may include concussions, sprains, fractures, or spinal injuries. This official diagnosis may prove vital if you decide to file an insurance claim or begin legal proceedings. Additionally, follow your doctor’s recommended treatment plan to help your recovery and avoid gaps in your medical record. Avoid Common Pitfalls That Could Weaken Your Position While you might be eager to put the incident behind you, certain avoidable mistakes can undermine your ability to seek fair compensation and protect your rights: Minimizing or dismissing your injuries: Even if you feel you can “shake it off,” take every concern seriously and follow medical advice. Posting about your accident on social media: It can be tempting to share your experience, but insurance companies or opposing parties can use social media posts against you. Restrict who can see your profile, and keep discussions about the accident or your condition offline. Not following through on medical care: Failing to refill prescriptions or skipping follow-up appointments could be interpreted as you not taking your injuries seriously. Giving statements without understanding your rights: If questioned by a property owner, insurance adjuster, or other party, avoid making statements that admit fault or downplay your injuries unless you have sought proper guidance. Awareness of these common pitfalls can save you from unnecessary complications and help you maintain a stronger position should you decide to pursue legal action.  Report the Accident Promptly Notifying the right individuals promptly can make a significant difference in establishing a proper record of your accident. Your specific reporting obligations vary based on the setting. If you fall in a commercial setting, like a grocery store, notify the manager or property owner so they can file an incident report. For falls on public property, consider contacting the relevant local authority or agency responsible for the area. Request a copy of any incident report, and keep it in a safe place. This document serves as official proof of your statement about what happened and when. Consider Professional Guidance for Your Next Steps Slip and fall cases can involve complex legal questions, especially when multiple parties or potential defendants are involved. You may wish to explore local laws and regulations to understand your rights. At Ahlander Injury Law , we focus on personal injury cases, including slip and fall accidents, and prioritize providing a clear understanding of your potential options. During an initial consultation, you can discuss the facts of your situation, learn about possible legal strategies, and decide whether taking legal action is in your best interests. Taking advantage of professional guidance can help you avoid missteps and successfully navigate your claim’s complexities. Learn Why Timely Action Matters Time is a crucial factor in slip and fall cases. Most states enforce statutes of limitations, which strictly limit how long you have to start legal proceedings. Delaying essential steps—such as seeking medical care, notifying the property owner, or consulting with professionals—could jeopardize your ability to recover compensation. Beyond legal considerations, timely action also helps you identify potential evidence before it disappears. For instance, a slippery substance might be cleaned up quickly, eliminating vital proof of the hazard. Witnesses’ memories can fade as well, making their statements less accurate over time. The sooner you act, the stronger your position will be if you choose to file a claim. Discover the Value of Proper Documentation and Care Not every slip and fall incident results in injuries serious enough to warrant a legal claim, but careful documentation and proactive measures can benefit you in both minor and severe cases. In situations where your injury may have lasting effects, thorough documentation ensures you have the information you need for insurance claims, potential rehabilitation, and peace of mind. Falls account for over 8 million hospital emergency room visits each year. With these statistics in mind, slip and fall accidents should not be dismissed as trivial events. Maintain Peace of Mind and Protect Your Rights A slip and fall can be an alarming experience that disrupts daily life, leaving you uncertain about your health and legal standing. With the right steps, you can safeguard your rights, secure a thorough diagnosis of your injuries, and ensure you have the support needed if you choose to explore legal options. It is within your power to regain control after a slip and fall accident. Collect the evidence you need, get prompt medical attention, and seek a qualified professional’s thoughts on how to move forward. Each of these decisions contributes to a solid foundation for both your recovery and potential legal claim should you decide to pursue one. If you have questions about your circumstances, reach out to Ahlander Injury Law for personalized legal support.
More Posts